The Legend of Brian Boru’s Crown
Brian Boru the legendary High King of Ireland is celebrated for uniting the island’s warring clans and remembered for +his death during the complex and bloody Battle of Clontarf in 1014. Yet a mystery endures the fate of his crown a relic symbolizing Ireland’s brief unity under his rule. For centuries rumours have suggested that this fabled crown lies hidden within the vaults of the Vatican. But it is believed that unlike their European counterparts early Irish kings did not wear crowns. Their authority was affirmed through symbolic rituals such as the Feis Temro at the Hill of Tara and the presentation of a white wand signifying sovereignty. Material crowns were absent from Gaelic tradition and no contemporary accounts suggest that Brian Boru possessed such an item.The notion of Brian Boru’s crown likely emerged centuries after his death influenced by nationalist revivalism in the 18th and 19th centuries.
Folklore describes it as a golden circlet adorned with Celtic knots and gemstones possibly blessed by the Church. The earliest written reference to this crown appears in the 1627 Annals of Clonmacnoise a translation by Conall Mac Geoghegan which claims that Brian’s son Donnchad brought the “Crown of Ireland” to Rome as penance for fratricide. However historians argue that this account may reflect metaphorical language, with “crown” symbolizing sovereignty rather than a physical object. After his deposition in 1063 Donnchad undertook a pilgrimage to Rome where he died and was buried at the Basilica of S. Stefano Rotondo.
A 19th-century plaque at the basilica references Donnchad and depicts a crown fuelling speculation that he gifted his father’s crown to the Pope. Following the Anglo-Norman invasion in the 12th century, the concept of a crown as a symbol of kingship became more prominent in Ireland influenced by continental practices. In 1176 King Henry II of England petitioned Pope Alexander III to send a crown for his son John reinforcing the association between the papacy and Irish sovereignty. Despite these connections no concrete evidence supports the existence of Brian Boru’s crown in the Vatican. Recent investigations by the Irish Embassy to the Holy See found no records of such a crown in the Vatican’s archives.
Historians including Professor Seán Duffy of Trinity College Dublin assert that Irish kings were not crowned and that the crown’s existence is likely metaphorical. In post Famine Ireland the legend of Brian Boru’s crown evolved into a symbol of lost sovereignty and cultural pride. The 1916 Rising and subsequent independence movement invoked Brian Boru as a proto nationalist hero. In 2014 commemorating the 1,000th anniversary of the Battle of Clontarf a replica “Brian Boru Millennium Crown” was crafted by jeweller Se O’Donoghue and unveiled at Dublin Castle reflecting the enduring power of this myth. The legend continues to inspire political action. In 2024 Clare TD Cathal Crowe called on the Irish government to engage with the Vatican to locate and repatriate the crown. He suggested forming a “mini-Indiana Jones” team to search for the artefact highlighting its cultural significance. Crowe emphasized that even if the crown’s existence remains unconfirmed the search itself could uncover other Irish artefacts held by the Vatican.
Lord Inchiquin Conor O’Brien a direct descendant of Brian Boru has also expressed interest in locating the crown. He believes that the crown may still lie in the Vatican vaults and has appealed to the Papal Nuncio for assistance. Archbishop Charles John Brown acknowledged the request noting that Pope Francis would relish the role of “Indiana Jones” in such a quest. While the physical existence of Brian Boru’s crown remains unsubstantiated its legend continues to captivate the imagination. As historian Dr. Patrick Wallace notes, “In the end the legend matters more than the object. Brian Boru’s true crown is the story itself” The tale of the crown whether fact or fiction serves as a testament to Ireland’s enduring quest to reclaim and celebrate its rich heritage. The Vatican with its centuries old history and vast repositories has long been the subject of intrigue and speculation. Beyond the well-known treasures and artefacts numerous legends and conspiracy theories suggest the existence of hidden relics and secrets within its walls. The Vatican Apostolic Archive formerly known as the Secret Archive spans over 50 miles of shelving and contains documents dating back over 12 centuries.
While many records are accessible to qualified researchers some materials remain restricted fuelling speculation about their contents including sensitive church documents and correspondences. And if the thought of Brian Boru’s Crown has got you curious here are some more reported Vatican mysteries to keep you going. The Menorah from the Second Temple: A persistent legend claims that the Vatican holds the original seven branched Menorah from Jerusalem’s Second Temple, taken by the Romans during the sack of Jerusalem in 70 CE. While some individuals assert they’ve seen such artefacts within the Vatican no concrete evidence has been presented to confirm this claim. The Knights Templar and the Chinon Parchment: The Knights Templar a medieval Christian military order were suppressed in the early 14th century.
In 2001 the discovery of the Chinon Parchment in the Vatican Apostolic Archive revealed that Pope Clement V had absolved the Templar leadership of heresy charges in 1308. This finding has fuelled theories that the Vatican may possess other Templar-related documents or treasures. The Third Secret of Fatima: In 1917, three Portuguese children reported visions of the Virgin Mary, who entrusted them with three secrets. While the first two were revealed promptly, the third remained undisclosed until 2000. Even after its release, some believe the Vatican withheld parts of the message, speculating it contains prophecies of global catastrophes or church scandals. Evidence of Extra-terrestrial Life: Conspiracy theories suggest the Vatican holds proof of extra-terrestrial life, including alien skulls or documents detailing contact with beings from other planets. These claims are unsubstantiated, and the Vatican has not acknowledged any such evidence. Unpublished Works of Michelangelo: Rumours persist that the Vatican’s art collection includes unpublished or unfinished works by Renaissance master Michelangelo.
While the Vatican houses numerous artworks including the Sistine Chapel ceiling, there’s no verified evidence of hidden Michelangelo pieces. Secret Confessionals and Hidden Chambers: Legends speak of concealed confessionals within the Vatican where popes could confess anonymously. Additionally, tales of hidden chambers and passageways such as the Passetto di Borgoa corridor connecting the Vatican to Castel Sant’Angelo add to the aura of mystery. The Illuminati and Hidden Symbols: Some theorists believe that the Vatican’s architecture and artworks contain symbols linked to the Illuminati a purported secret society. These claims often point to specific designs or patterns in Vatican structures though mainstream historians and scholars dismiss such interpretations as speculative. The Vatican’s Independent Time Zone: An intriguing fact is that Vatican City operates on its own time zone, separate from Rome. This unique aspect has led to various theories about its significance though it’s primarily administrative. The Disappearance of Pope John VIII: Historical accounts mention Pope John VIII who some believe was a woman disguised as a man known as Pope Joan. While the story is widely regarded as a legend it contributes to the mystique surrounding the Vatican’s history.
Hashtags: #BrianBoru'sCrown 
